Aftermath (Book 2 of "The Promise Papers - Sinful Secrets")
Pierce had been in a panic ever since the annual summer retreat, because he was just sure that some of the local teenagers had spied on him when he and two other counselors had eagerly gangbanged sexy Chelsea Keegan from nearby Hazard Valley. But he never expected shy, meek little Melly to confront him, and threaten him with exposure...if he didn't bang her just like he'd been banging Chelsea! More
Melly had seen her sexy church counsellor fucking the hell out of Miz Keegan at the annual spring retreat, and she was tired of being a ‘good girl.’ She thought Pierce was incredibly hot, and wanted him to be her first lover. And she wasn’t above using blackmail to coerce him, if she had to...
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
“I never saw anyone having sex before.” Her clear voice broke the silence before he could figure out what to say to her.
“You shouldn’t have been spying on us.”
“I know.” She flashed him a quick rueful smile. “I didn’t mean to. But I heard Miz Keegan scream, and I thought maybe she was hurt. So I ran over to see, and...well... I saw everything you were doing to her.”
Pierce took a deep breath. “Why are you telling me this?” he demanded.
She stopped and looked up at him, and her big eyes seemed to sparkle with excitement. “Because I want you to do it to me, too. Right now.”
“What?” Pierce gaped at her in horrified shock. “Melly, you can’t just... My God!”
“I’m not afraid.” Her small breasts started to rise and fall in quick little pants as she looked him up and down...and then boldly fastened her rapt gaze on his swelling groin.
His lips twisted into a bitter scowl. “You should be. If I was foolish enough to do what you want, I’d put you in the hospital, no matter how careful I was.”
“I’ll tell everyone I know what I saw.” It was her trump card, but her voice shook as she made the bold threat. “And they’ll believe me, because lots of the other kids were spying on you, too! We all saw how you were sticking it inside her, and juicing all over her while she bounced on those other two guys!”
Oh God, it was worse than he’d feared. Not just Melly, but who-knew how many other teenagers, as well!
“Melly.” Sighing, he settled down onto a fallen log, and patted it invitingly. “What you’re asking of me isn’t just crazy, it’s impossible. No matter how much I might want to, I can’t make love to you. I just physically can’t. I’m too big. And there’s no way I can make it smaller.”
She thought about that for a moment, then squared her small chin. “I don’t care. I still want you to be the one.”
“No.” Pierce tried to sound firm, but it was tough to breathe. And that damned baseball bat between his muscular thighs was getting bigger and harder with every passing moment...