This heart-warming Christmas series begins with a young Englisch family, who experience an unfathomable tragedy. When eighteen-year-old Shannon Parker becomes the sole caretaker of her three younger siblings, she has no idea how she's going to provide for the Christmas season fast approaching, let alone their basic daily needs. Until her five-year-old brother, Jaycee, mistakes an Amish bishop for Santa Claus. None of them can imagine the wonderful things God has in store for them! A delightful series that will stay with readers for years to come.

Unlikely Amish Christmas

Series Order
Newest Title Rating
Unlikely Santa (An Amish Christmas Story) by
Series: Unlikely Amish Christmas, Book 1. Price: $5.99 USD. Words: 46,690. Language: English. Published: November 1, 2019 . Categories: Fiction » Holiday » Christmas, Fiction » Christian » Amish & Mennonite
When young Jaycee Parker mistakes Amish Bishop Christopher Stoltz for Santa Claus, neither realized how their lives would change. Will this unlikely encounter be the miracle they need this holiday season? A faith-filled Christmas story sure to bring a smile to your face and warm your heart! From Early Readers: "This story is totally adorable." "...perfect Hallmark movie!" "Wesley is my new hero!"
Unlikely Sweethearts (An Amish Christmas Story) by
Series: Unlikely Amish Christmas, Book 2. Price: $5.99 USD. Words: 40,820. Language: English. Published: November 1, 2020 . Categories: Fiction » Christian » Amish & Mennonite, Fiction » Christian » Romance
He’s bent on breaking the rules. She’s determined to keep them. Sparks fly when opposites attract in this fun Christmas romance! Will Randy and Holly find joy…and love…this holiday season?
Unlikely Singing (An Amish Christmas Story) by
Series: Unlikely Amish Christmas. Price: $3.99 USD. Words: 17,760. Language: English. Published: December 5, 2022 . Categories: Fiction » Christian » Romance, Fiction » Christian » Amish & Mennonite
A missed opportunity. A summer of regret. And a Christmas miracle. The moment Christopher Stoltz met the mysterious young Amish woman at his cousin’s wedding, he knew there was something special about her. So, when they cross paths again, he vows not to make the same mistake twice. Will it take a Christmas miracle for them to find their happily ever after?
Unlikely Season (An Amish Christmas Story) by
Series: Unlikely Amish Christmas, Book 4. Price: $5.99 USD. Words: 25,920. Language: English. Published: November 1, 2022 . Categories: Fiction » Christian » Romance, Fiction » Christian » Amish & Mennonite
Christmas for the Stoltz family has been different ever since young Jaycee Parker mistook an Amish bishop for Santa Claus. Now that James Stoltz’s folks have been shunned by their Amish community, his family finally has a chance at a real relationship with them—something impossible when his sons Wesley and Randy were growing up. A Christmas story of faith, hope and love you can't put down.